Authors: Y.-Y. Zhang, H. Andernach, C. A. Caretta, T. H. Reiprich, H. Boehringer, E. Puchwein, D. Sijacki, M. Girardi
http://arxiv.org/abs/1011.3018v1
http://arxiv.org/abs/1011.3018v1
We present relations between X-ray luminosity and velocity dispersion ($L-\sigma$), X-ray luminosity and gas mass ($L-M_{\rm gas}$), and between cluster radius and velocity dispersion ($r_{500}-\sigma$) for 62 galaxy clusters in the HIFLUGCS, an X-ray flux-limited sample minimizing bias toward any cluster morphology. Our analysis is based on in total ~1.3 Msec clean X-ray XMM-Newton data and on 13439 cluster member galaxies with redshifts. The presence of cool cores is one of the major contributors to the scatter of the $L-\sigma$ relation. When the cool-core corrected X-ray luminosity is used the intrinsic scatter is reduced to 0.27 dex. Even with the X-ray luminosity corrected for the cool core, the scatter caused by the presence of cool cores dominates for the low-mass systems. The scatter caused by the non-cool-core clusters does not strongly depend on the mass range, and becomes dominant in the high-mass regime. The observed $L-\sigma$ relation agrees with the self-similar prediction, matches that of a simulated sample with AGN feedback, disregarding six clusters with $<45$ cluster members with spectroscopic redshifts, and shows a common trend of increasing scatter toward the low-mass end, i.e., systems with $\sigma<500$ km/s. A comparison of observations with simulations indicates an AGN feedback driven impact in the low-mass regime. The best fits of the $L-M_{\rm gas}$ relations for the disturbed clusters and undisturbed clusters in the observational sample match very well the simulated samples with and without AGN feedback, respectively. This suggests one main cause of the scatter being AGN activities providing feedback in different phases, e.g. during a feedback cycle. The slope and scatter of the observed $r_{500}-\sigma$ relation is similar to that of the simulated sample with AGN feedback except for a small offset but still within the scatter.
Testing gravity using the growth of large scale structure in the Universe
Future galaxy surveys hope to distinguish between the dark energy and modified gravity scenarios for the accelerating expansion of the Universe using the distortion of clustering in redshift space. The aim is to model the form and size of the distortion in order to infer the rate at which large scale structure grows. We test this hypothesis and assess the performance of current theoretical models for the redshift space distortion using very large volume N-body simulations of the gravitational instability process. We simulate competing cosmological models which have identical expansion histories - one is a quintessence dark energy model with a scalar field and the other is a modified gravity model with a time varying gravitational constant - and demonstrate that they do indeed produce different redshift space distortions. This is the first time this approach has been verified using a technique that can follow the growth of structure at the required level of accuracy. Our comparisons show that theoretical models for the redshift space distortion based on linear perturbation theory, which are currently in widespread use, give a surprisingly poor description of the simulation results. Furthermore, the application of such models can give rise to catastrophic systematic errors leading to an incorrect interpretation of the observations. We show that an improved model is able to extract the correct growth rate. Further enhancements to theoretical models of redshift space distortions, calibrated against simulations, are needed if we are to fully exploit the forthcoming high precision clustering measurements.
No comments:
Post a Comment